Keep It Simple Stupid (KISS)

Keep it simple stupid, in short KISS, is a popular expression used in various areas. The approach aims to keep every step in a process as simple as possible. KISS is sometimes even used as a framework for life. Certainly, KISS approach can be applied and is applied for variable frequency drives. Especially when it comes to reliability and availability.

Keep it simple stupid principle in critical applications

According to wikipedia [1], KISS as a design principle was first noted by U.S. Navy in 1960. Other sources report about extensive use of KISS principle in aeronautics. Obviously, military and space applications belong to those requiring highest level of reliability. So why not applying KISS for reliability of VFDs and electric drive systems?

KISS – Everything is better when it is simple

Keep it simple stupid method is based on principle that everything is better when it is simple. That applies design practices, software architecture, instructions, learning processes etc.

Keep the VFD design simple stupid

How to apply the principle in medium voltage drives? There are several areas such as hardware design, protection concept or software architecture. KISS aims to eliminate the root cause of the problem rather than solving the consequences.

Hardware design

VFD topology utilizing medium voltage semiconductors with high power density and low parts count is one example. Instead of using large quantity of components and engineering complex redundancy concepts the same or even better reliability figures can be achieved with low parts count and no semiconductor redundancy.

  • 5 MW, 4.16 kV neutral point clamped (NPC) inverter:
    • 12 active switches
    • 18 diodes
  • 5 MW, 4.16 kV multi-cell inverter:
    • 48 active switches
    • 48 diodes

And it does not involve power semiconductors only. Similar situation is for example with cooling pipes in case of a liquid cooled VFD. Inverter with high quantity of semiconductors also requires large quantity of plastic pipes distributing the water to the individual heat sinks. Thus increasing the probability of leakages.

Absence of fuses

Use of fuses in medium voltage VFDs is tricky.  The fuse needs to have very quick response to provide required protection of semiconductor devices. Fuses also naturally age making the maintenance somewhat cumbersome. And again, there is the topic of quantity. In the example of a 5 MW, 4.16 kV multi-cell inverter a total amount of 36 fuses is needed (some manufacturers reduce the quantity to 24 pcs using two fuses per cell). A fuseless design will be more in line with KISS principles. It reduces the parts count, simplifies the maintenance job throughout the lifetime of equipment and boosts the availability.

Sensorless speed control

Elimination of a speed encoder can also be seen as a step towards KISS. Performance of an encoder is affected by multiple factors such as physical distance between inverter and motor, type of signal, interfences with other equipment (EMC topic), installation aspects (e.g. unbalance), environmental factors (dust, vibration) etc.

In sensorless variant the speed is calculated in VFD software based on electrical signals that are already available. Of course, there are high performance applications that require speed and/or position encoder [3].

Filterless design

If possible, a filterless VFD design is preferred. This applies mainly for the grid side filter. Since the grid parameters are project-specific a grid filter is usually an engineered solution. The purpose of a filter is to absorb specific harmonics and eventually compensate the reactive power. However, it is rather challenging to make a filter design that is robust and stable during grid faults and other unusual operation states.

On the machine side there is practically always some kind of filter (as minimum a dv/dt filter reducing the voltage slope and ensuring compatibility within the inverter-cable-motor system [4]). However, machine side has somewhat different aspects. On one hand there is the variable output frequency. On the other hand it is a clearly defined system with well known machine parameters making it easier to manage.

Those were just few examples that illustrate how KISS is applied in the design of a medium voltage VFD. The same philosophy can be used on a drive system level by simplifying the system components and better integration of certain functionality.

Summary

There are various approaches how to reach high availability of system. One of them is ‘Keep It Simple (Stupid)’, known as KISS. The principle originates from military use where reliability means everything and is applied for industrial applications as well. In VFD world it is achieved in various ways, for example by using robust components with high power density and low parts count.

The concept is proven and backed by a large globally installed base of medium voltage VFDs designed according KISS guideline.

Acknowledgement

We would like to thank Mr. Benny Nyberg who inspired us to write this short post.

References

[1] KISS principle (wikipedia), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KISS_principle

[2] Reliability and availability series, https://mb-drive-services.com/category/reliability-and-availability/

[3] Encoders in motor drive applications, https://mb-drive-services.com/encoders_part1/

[4] Long motor cables, https://mb-drive-services.com/long-motor-cables/


1 Comment

Power semiconductors - Comparison of IGBT and IGCT - MB Drive Services · February 12, 2022 at 1:03 pm

[…] High power rating translates into more compact design, lower parts count and better reliability (KISS principle – see our previous post […]

Comments are closed.